{
  "task": "R23-001",
  "reviewed_utc": "2026-11-10T12:37:41.529071+00:00",
  "status": "accepted_as_numerical_benchmark_only",
  "actual_executor": "native R3 saved chat SIM-R3-001",
  "observed_native_execution": {
    "tool_id": "exec-9c30cefc-504f-4a2a-a6f6-45e9207ca154",
    "status": "completed",
    "exit_code": 0,
    "duration_ms": 47572,
    "entry": "run_all('he')",
    "completion_marker": "HE_REPRODUCTION_COMPLETE"
  },
  "supervisor_review": {
    "source_PDF_pages_actually_viewed": [
      3,
      4,
      5,
      8
    ],
    "source_text_pages_read": [
      6,
      7
    ],
    "MATLAB_implementation_read": true,
    "table2_and_equation_extracts_nonempty": true,
    "plots_actually_opened_and_inspected": true,
    "parameter_tuning_to_target_detected": false,
    "target_values": "source p7 approximate published maxima3.57h and1.44h",
    "interpretation": "six-rotor total power summed with per-rotor induced velocity reproduces the H2 maximum; two literal ambiguity branches preserved",
    "graphics_correction_required": "contour figure dark axes/background must be set to white for final report; scientific source values not changed"
  },
  "source_reported_and_reproduced": {
    "branch": "six_rotor_consistent_total",
    "max_H2_h": 3.5720418247345025,
    "mass_at_max_H2_kg": 21.625,
    "max_Li250_h": 1.4558391066204888,
    "mass_at_max_Li_kg": 16.825000000000003,
    "mass_closed_H2_max_h": 3.4016206311156107,
    "mass_closed_opt_kg": 21.625,
    "relative_difference_from_paper_H2_3p57": 0.0005719397015413463,
    "relative_difference_from_paper_Li_1p44": 0.010999379597561587
  },
  "accepted_scope": "numerical reconstruction of the published hexacopter route; not four-rotor optimum, original code identity, or flight validation",
  "original_fit_covariance_available": false,
  "original_confidence_prediction_bands_reconstructed": false,
  "full_contract_completed": false,
  "evidence": [
    {
      "path": "reports/06_reports/03_endurance_simulation/SIM-R3-001/he-reproduction-summary.json",
      "sha256": "c1e24ccffd43e453c4f98cbc6470165e7014f60d3b843751ac107ece28401b0c",
      "bytes": 3111
    },
    {
      "path": "reports/04_models/R23-001/he-reproduction/run_he_reproduction.m",
      "sha256": "93fe7507e81ce240370913d0f67854f1e417d6c842830115bfb02ee86d0e50cc",
      "bytes": 7119
    },
    {
      "path": "reports/04_models/R23-001/he-reproduction/published-table2.csv",
      "sha256": "5a4bed33925c4aeaf7fb092942245c505bf9e3cf8d3a71843da5400c4b7acc93",
      "bytes": 5368
    },
    {
      "path": "reports/04_models/R23-001/he-reproduction/published-equations-and-audit.csv",
      "sha256": "d823e4d5455af911f8bb9e6bbe6a2b55d98d73cce5415dcf28030398f6454428",
      "bytes": 5365
    },
    {
      "path": "reports/05_simulation/R23-001/runs/he-reproduction/original-route.csv",
      "sha256": "b5f3ad8186a79559bd9056b4466af02fc394c9cd4baa5b14eeb4c57e88b17ae3",
      "bytes": 384445
    },
    {
      "path": "reports/05_simulation/R23-001/runs/he-reproduction/he-original-results.mat",
      "sha256": "52d5f44b7df89e7e7c87f06ef00bf55a56962ee03f5cfcffeb4f3b05d676aa11",
      "bytes": 2251252
    },
    {
      "path": "reports/05_simulation/R23-001/runs/he-reproduction/matlab.log",
      "sha256": "526ace921f028f8fc457ecd72466f48847636a0e29d776ec669e53a698c2dba5",
      "bytes": 70
    },
    {
      "path": "reports/05_simulation/R23-001/figures/he-original-route.png",
      "sha256": "3d84a3dcd81b179363f52ec6354ab7271cad572d0392f1ef315c460c8da192b0",
      "bytes": 119562
    },
    {
      "path": "reports/05_simulation/R23-001/figures/he-original-mass-payload-contours.png",
      "sha256": "de6c56f88db1177fd5d5c8553cd53d1350fcc18e73ff68a4a25e5feedc29f086",
      "bytes": 128960
    }
  ]
}
